Purchasing carts that lock and safety gates? Consumers pontificate on retailers’ anti-theft ways

Mark Barrey says a current buying journey to his neighbourhood Zehrs in Waterloo, Ont., was humiliating. 

He stated simply earlier than leaving Zehrs, a grocery chain owned by Loblaw, a “ridiculously loud” alarm went off and the wheels on his buying cart locked.

“I am standing there, my neighbours strolling previous me, me like I’ve completed one thing mistaken,” stated Barrey. “It was extremely embarrassing.”

He says a retailer safety worker checked his buyer receipt, which proved he hadn’t stolen something. Regardless that he was now within the clear, Barrey stated he needed to wait with the motionless cart — with the alarm nonetheless blaring — till the worker discovered the distant machine used to deactivate its wheel lock.

“There was no rationalization … no apology,” stated Barrey. “If you are going to deal with me like I’m a legal, I’m not going to patronize your institutions.”

Shopping cart wheels.
CBC Information interviewed a number of prospects who stated, when exiting a Loblaw-owned retailer just lately, the wheels on their buying cart locked they usually needed to present their receipts. (Keith Burgess/CBC)

In response to the Retail Council of Canada, retail theft is on the rise, fuelled partly by organized crime and inflation. Though Canada’s inflation charge declined final month, meals, and mortgage prices stay stubbornly excessive

A number of retailers, corresponding to Loblaw and Walmart, have stepped up safety. Nonetheless, some ways have sparked buyer backlash, corresponding to receipt checks and Loblaw locking wheels on prospects’ carts.

“It pissed me off,” stated Yvette Ogle of Kitchener, Ont. She says, final month, her cart’s wheels out of the blue locked when leaving her native Zehrs, and he or she needed to present her receipt to get them unlocked. 

“I did completely nothing mistaken that day and it was simply, I really feel, very heavy-handed.”

Rebecca Lawrence stated, two weeks in the past, she endured the identical expertise at a Loblaw-owned Superstore in Dartmouth, N.S. 

“Why am I being singled out?'” she stated. “It does not really feel nice given the truth that we’re in a meals insecurity disaster and costs are going up and up.”

Loblaw responds

Loblaw instructed CBC Information that organized retail crime is rising, with thieves stealing giant quantities of expensive gadgets corresponding to cosmetics and child formulation, which they resell on-line. 

“We have needed to make some adjustments in how our shops function to cease this crime … whereas on the similar time sustaining a welcoming and handy buyer expertise,” stated spokesperson Catherine Thomas in an e mail. 

WATCH | Mark Barrey describes the second the wheels on his buying cart locked: 

Humiliated on the grocery retailer: anti-theft ways anger consumers

Grocery retailers in Canada, like Loblaws and Walmart, are upping safety to fight an increase in theft, however a few of the ways are sparking buyer backlash.

She didn’t reply questions in regards to the firm’s cart wheel locking system, or clarify why sure consumers are focused. 

Nonetheless, Thomas did say that Loblaw is “working to search out the precise steadiness” with its safety measures and welcomes buyer enter.

Barrey says he complained to Loblaw about his expertise on social media, however by no means heard again. 

On Wednesday, Loblaw reported a quarterly revenue of $508 million up to now three months, as meals and drug gross sales proceed to develop. 

Gates in shops

Consumers are additionally complaining about steel safety gates just lately put in in some shops with designated entry and exit factors.

Tristan Capacchione of Montreal says his native Loblaw-owned Provigo has put up boundaries all through the grocery retailer, together with gates at self-checkout that staff open as consumers exit. 

“It is simply irritating. It feels such as you’re being restricted in your motion,” stated Capacchione. “They’re selecting to fight theft in a manner that disadvantages the common buyer.”

Loblaw didn’t reply questions on gates besides to say they seem to be a theft deterrent.

A security gate set up at a Provigo store in Montreal.
Many Loblaw shops have put in safety gates with designated entry and exit factors. (Submitted by Tristan Capacchione)

Walmart Canada has put in gates in a majority of its shops, in response to the corporate. 

Diane Ray of Victoria stated she just lately encountered a closed exit gate at a Walmart in Nanaimo, B.C. 

Ray stated she paid for her gadgets at self-checkout, after which purchased one closing merchandise on the retailer’s pharmacy. She says when she tried to depart, an worker on the gate stood in her manner. 

“I used to be on the scooter. I could not simply rise up and stroll previous her,” stated Ray, who makes use of a mobility scooter. “And the gate was nonetheless closed, so it meant I wasn’t going wherever.”

Diane Ray sits on her mobility scooter.
Diane Ray of Victoria says she was indignant after she was blocked from exiting Walmart on her scooter till she confirmed her receipts and answered questions on the place she purchased her gadgets within the retailer. (Submitted by Stephen Ray)

Ray stated the worker demanded to see her receipts and peppered her with questions on her purchases. 

“I hadn’t completed something mistaken,” stated Ray. “I felt humiliated, indignant — I used to be indignant and I felt like I used to be being handled unfairly, unjustly,”

She stated the worker ultimately returned her receipts and let her go away. Ray’s husband, Stephen, stated he complained on the retailer’s customer support desk, however nothing ever got here of it. 

Walmart responds

Walmart spokesperson Sarah Kennedy instructed CBC Information in an e mail that the corporate is “dedicated to offering a protected and inclusive setting,” and is wanting into Ray’s case. 

Kennedy added that Walmart’s gates have been put in “over time” to “assist handle the directional circulate of shoppers into and out of our shops.” 

Lawyer and client rights advocate Daniel Tsai says retailers cannot forestall consumers from leaving a retailer — except they’ve proof of wrongdoing. 

“If you happen to’re blocked from leaving and you have not completed something mistaken, that signifies that they’ve engaged in potential false imprisonment, and that opens them as much as a lawsuit,” stated Tsai, who relies in Toronto. 

He added that locking the wheels of a buying cart could possibly be deemed false imprisonment if a client felt trapped when their cart stopped transferring.

“The important thing consideration right here is the psychology of the person,” he stated. “So if the cart locks up, that [could give] them the impression, in all probability fairly moderately so, that they cannot go away.”

The Retail Council of Canada (RCC) says theft-prevention measures profit consumers, as a result of when retailers lose cash as a result of crime, they increase costs. 

‘”Theft prices Canadian retailers billions of {dollars} a yr, prices which are handed on to you and I as shoppers once we buy groceries,” stated RCC spokesperson Michelle Wasylyshen in an e mail. 

However Tsai stated if a retailer’s anti-theft ways anger prospects, they danger dropping enterprise. 

By